| 1995 | John Boughton | 2002 | George Daniel | 2009 | Wayne Garst |
| 1996 | Ted Counts | 2003 | John Mastin | 2010 | Richard Romanus |
| 1997 | Guy Townsend | 2004 | Robert “Bobby” G. Dotson | 2011 | Wimpy Isgett |
| 1998 | Steve Proffitt | 2005 | G. Ray Boone, CAI | 2012 | Jerome Clark |
| 1999 | Grayson Smith | 2006 | Buddy Updike | ||
| 2000 | Rick Manley | 2007 | Lee Williams | ||
| 2001 | Ken Farmer | 2008 | Stanley King, Sr. Gaines Dickinson |
